ELEPHANT CORNER: City Shouldn’t Meddle With Pt. Breeze Developers

Filed under: Columns,Latest News |

Last week, COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON sought the approval of City Council for his proposal that the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority build affordable housing in Point Breeze. In order to execute Johnson’s plan, the City, through its power of eminent domain, will need to force private homeowners and developers to sell two-thirds of properties designated for the project. The City owns the rest. This is an abuse of the City’s power of eminent domain. Condemning properties, in this elephant’s opinion, should be reserved for projects that benefit a very large group of people, like needed highway additions.

Is Johnson really looking out for the working poor, or is he trying to stall the economic development of the neighborhood so that middle-class people, who may not be reliable votes for him, do not move into Point Breeze? Similar policies have been pursued by other politicians and have had unintended negative consequences referred to as the “Curley Effect”.

Boston MAYOR JAMES CURLEY pursued policies that encouraged the middle- and upper-class Anglo-Saxon Protestants to move out of the city because they did not vote for him, the way the poorer Irish did. The upshot was the tax base moved out of the city, leaving fewer funds for city services and, perhaps more importantly, government jobs for Curley’s constituents.

Similarly, building public housing in an increasingly attractive area will dampen real-estate values. This will not only take money out of the hands of middle-class homeowners and developers, but also from long-time and economically disadvantaged residents who could see real financial gain from the appreciation of their properties. Increasing subsidized housing in Point Breeze will slow down the development of housing and commercial space attractive to the middle class whose tax dollars are greatly needed by the City. The City owns abandoned and condemned properties in other areas of the city that would actually benefit from new subsidized housing.

Last Wednesday, local Republicans meet at Paddy Whacks for their monthly Happy Hour. Organizer DENISE FUREY decided the herd needed to focus on the positive and invited LINDA KERNS, the lawyer who orchestrated the Republicans’ election-day legal efforts, to speak. She discussed the major inroads PAGOP made into limiting voter fraud on election day. Primarily through the work of JOE DeFELICE and ANNIE HAVEY, PAGOP identified and received credentials for roughly 300 Minority Inspectors for polling places that have not seen Republican election-board workers in 50 years. On election day, there were numerous incidents where Judges of Election called the police to have the Republican election workers removed. Kerns had roughly 70 polling places where she had to send Republican attorneys to intervene and in some cases needed to have our Minority Inspectors seated by court order with the help of the city Sheriff.

The 300 Minority Inspectors recruited by the PAGOP were in large part African American. LEW HARRIS, leader of the 29th Ward, with help from Annie Havey, leader of the 40th Ward, has formed the Philadelphian Republicans of Color (PhillyROCs). The state-affiliated side of the party has actively recruited committee people and ward leaders in minority areas.

MIKE MEEHAN, who leads the traditional version of Republican City Committee, appointed three non-minority people from South Philadelphia to head wards in minority areas in North Philadelphia for his version of the Republican City Committee. In one case, the ward had a duly elected leader, VICKIE FREEMAN. In the 13th Ward, the ward leader had resigned, but there were a number of active committee people Meehan failed to contact, including the Ward Chairwoman LINDA DIGGS, who was more than willing to step up to be the ward leader.

Collectively, we elephants do need to improve our message to the African American community. We must begin by working with existing Black Republicans and treating them with respect as our equals.

Share
PDF Printer    Send article as PDF   

One Response to ELEPHANT CORNER: City Shouldn’t Meddle With Pt. Breeze Developers

  1. I think that the viewpoints of the author mentioned in the first four paragraphs of this article are repugnant.

    There is a large amout of construction currently going on in the Point Breeze neighborhood. Most of it appears to be unsubsidized by the Prhiladelphia Redeveopment Authority. When the author mentions middle-class people moving into the neighborhood it seems like a code word for non-minority people.

    I applaud Councilman Johnson for standing up for affordable housing. One only needs to look at the changes in the Graduate Hospital area to realize that many people have been priced out of purchasing homes in that area.

    There are some homes now which have been built by Community Ventures targeted for affordable buyers that are still sitting unsold. These unsold homes reflect the fact that buyers must be creditworthy and have good jobs to obtain a mortgage.

    My recent work at the polls in the 36th Ward, 35th Division revealed that we are already a diverse neighborhood. We all benefit from diversity and a mix of affordable and market-rate housing.

    Michael E. Bell
    November 23, 2012 at 2:07 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>