Firefighters Battle Effort To Cut Paramedics

Filed under: Labor,Subject Categories |


Firefighters Union Local 22 staged a press conference on Wednesday and appeared at a civil service hearing this morning to voice their concerns over an administration plan to remove one paramedic from every medic unit in the city and replace them with less-qualified EMTs.

REVIEWING Local 22 President Joe Schulle’s remarks calling to retain crucial paramedic personnel are his teammates, from left, Karen Boyle,Jerry Kots, Schulle and Dan Oakes.

REVIEWING Local 22 President Joe Schulle’s remarks calling to retain crucial paramedic personnel are his teammates, from left, Karen Boyle,Jerry Kots, Schulle and Dan Oakes.

Joe Schulle, president of the union, explained to the Civil Service Commissioners, “Paramedics must graduate an intense two-year training program. EMTs only need to attend a 10-week training course.”

He noted the City’s cost-cutting move, achieved by a lower pay scale for EMTs, will make the city’s residents – especially the elderly – less safe. This change in the staffing of medic units does not require the approval of City Council.

Councilman Jim Kenney has advised Schulle he will introduce legislative initiatives to prevent the City’s plan from being enacted.

Schulle advised the Commission national safety standards recommend two paramedics and two EMTs respond to all Advance Life Support dispatch assignments. He mentioned the American Heart Association said, “In those systems that have attained survival rates higher than 20% for patients with ventricular fibrillation, response teams included as a minimum, two ALS providers and 2 BLS providers.”

The City claims there is no reduction in care because two people will be on scene and a paramedic will be on scene more often.

Schulle’s response is that “on critical emergencies, one paramedics is not enough to give adequate care to the patient. In a cardiac arrest, for instance, multiple equally important medical interventions must be given simultaneously. On these critical calls, equipment needs to be monitored and the medical command doctor maybe contacted. Those functions need to be done by the second paramedic, trained to do so.”

He added, “The initial actions performed in the emergency rooms are nearly identical to the care provided by the paramedics on the street. One paramedic cannot accomplish all of the medical interventions needed simultaneously.”

Three members of the administration  also held a press conference following that of the Firefighters to explain the proposed deployment model they were advocating for City paramedics and emergency medical technical.  Holding the conference were Michael Resnick, Director of Public Safety; David Gallagher, Deputy Commissioner, EMS, and Derrick Sawyer, Deputy Fire Commissioner of Operations. 


Join over 3.000 visitors who are receiving our newsletter and learn how to optimize your blog for search engines, find free traffic, and monetize your website.
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.
PDF24    Send article as PDF   

One Response to Firefighters Battle Effort To Cut Paramedics

  1. As a Registered Nurse who works in an ER, I would have to say that this is one of the most-ridiculous efforts of trying to cut costs without regard to public safety.

    It has been well studied and documented that the best outcomes in patients with stroke, cardiac arrest and MI along with other lethal events is achieved by high standards of prehospital care. Decreasing the amount of EMS responders that are trained and experienced to provide care at this level by half will decrease positive patient outcomes by at least the same amount. There is a big difference between basic care and advanced life support. We can find the money somewhere else.

    1. How about decreasing the size of Philadelphia government? 2. Combating corruption and redirecting those dollars back to public safety. I’m all for finding waste but this is not one of them.

    Robin Gilchrist
    March 28, 2014 at 8:21 am

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *